X-Ray Telescopes

by S. Prasad Ganti

All the X-ray telescopes are in space. None on the ground. There are optical, infra-red, radio telescopes on the ground, but not X-rays. For the simple reason that X-rays coming from outer space cannot penetrate the earth’s atmosphere. Fortunately for us, else we would have been toast. No life would have been possible on earth. 

Chandra is an X-ray telescope, up in space since 1999. It recently completed 25 years in space. It was expected to last only five years, but had performed excellently for the last quarter of a century. X-rays, in minor doses, help with medical imaging of body inners. But in outer space, the dosages are very high and result from a supernova remnant or a black hole. An X-ray telescope helps in studying such cosmic objects. 

Chandra is an engineering marvel which has the cleanest pairs of mirrors. There are 4 pairs which are polished to the smoothness of a few atoms and are precisely aligned. X-ray telescopes require much higher levels of precision than optical telescopes because the wavelength of X-rays is much smaller than visible light. The unevenness of the surface of the mirror should be much less than the wavelength. Chandra’s great accomplishments have been the discovery of Cassiopeia A, which is the remnant of a supernova. The discovery of the Bullet cluster provided evidence of dark matter. Hundreds of black holes were also discovered.   

There are 2 X-ray observatories which have been launched in the last three years. To study the polarization of X-rays from extremely bright objects (not visual but in X-ray terms). Polarimeter is an instrument which is used to study the polarization of the X-rays, basically the alignment of electric and magnetic fields. They are always perpendicular to each other, but which direction is the electric component is the question. Polarization of X-rays can reveal the source from where they are coming and also the magnetic fields and the geometry of the source region. Initial observations of the Crab nebula, powered by a neutron star at its core; and the Cygnus X1 black hole X-ray binary are very encouraging. 

Another X-ray observatory called the Einstein probe, is a joint mission by the Chinese Academy of Sciences, European Space Agency (ESA) and the Max Planck Institute for Extraterrestrial Physics. Its goals are to identify and study new and transient sources of high-energy X-rays. The events are very short lived and shift from location to location, with very little chance of repeating at the same location. Such events are triggered by inactive black holes and merger of neutron stars. It was launched in Jan, 2024. 

The Einstein probe  has a Wide-field X-ray Telescope (WXT), with a lobster like eye with a 180 degree field of view. The telescope inspired by the crustacean eyes works by reflection rather than refraction. The wide field helps the telescope to observe a large swath of the sky at a time.   

The X-ray observatories form a part of the multi messenger astronomy where observations are made in several parts of the electromagnetic spectrum like radio waves, infrared waves, light, x-rays, and gamma rays. The instruments and the observatories are different engineering for each part of the electromagnetic spectrum. Except for x-rays and gamma rays, the rest of them can be observed using ground based observatories as well. 

Given below is the picture of Chandra X-ray telescope, courtesy NASA.

Posted in December 2024, Sidereal Times | Tagged , | Leave a comment

A Message from Princeton University Press

Stay starstruck this November with Princeton’s spell-binding collection of books on astronomy, including the brand-new Hidden in the Heavens, a NASA insider’s account of the Kepler mission and its bewildering discoveries. Take some time to learn from women who broke down barriers and changed the face of modern astronomy in The Sky Is for Everyone. Then it’s time to pack your bags to go Back to the Moon, one scientist’s inspiring vision, and onward to explore the real science behind interstellar expeditions in A Traveler’s Guide to the Stars. Your holiday gift list won’t be complete without touring the most spectacular sights in astronomy as observed in Welcome to the Universe in 3D, the New York Times bestseller from Neil deGrasse Tyson, Michael A. Strauss, J. Richard Gott, and Robert J. Vanderbei.

Princeton titles make stellar choices for holiday or donor gifts, book clubs, and to share with astronomy club members. For information on ordering and available discounts, email Barbara_Tonetti@press.princeton.edu.

Price:$29.95
ISBN:9780691242477 
Published (US):Oct 29, 2024
Copyright:2024
Pages:272
Size:6.13 x 9.25 in.
Illus:8 page color insert + 4 b/w illus.
Main_subject:Physics & Astronomy

An insider’s account of the NASA mission that changed our understanding of planets, planetary systems, and the stars they orbit.

Jason Steffen, a former scientist on NASA’s Kepler mission, offers a unique, inside account of the work of the Kepler science team, mapping the progress of the mission from the launch of the rocket that carried Kepler into space to the revelations of the data that began to flow to the supercomputer back at NASA—evidence of strange new worlds unlike anything found in our own solar system.

Price:$19.95
ISBN:9780691253916 
Published: Oct 31, 2023
Pages:504
Size:5.25 x 8 in.
Illus:72 b/w illus.
Main_subject: Physics & Astronomy

An inspiring anthology of writings by trailblazing women astronomers from around the globe.

Trimble and Weintraub bring together essays by women who reached for the stars in this uplifting anthology. . . . Filled with moving testimonies and awe-inspiring discoveries, this is a wonderful tribute to the joys of science and the tough road many women had on the way to forging their careers.

Price:$29.95
ISBN:9780691215235 
Published: Nov 1, 2022
Copyright:2022
Pages:304
Size:5.5 x 8.5 in.
Illus:10 b/w illus.
Main_subject: Physics & Astronomy

A scientist’s inspiring vision of our return to the Moon as humanity’s next thrilling step in space exploration.

Just over half a century since Neil Armstrong first stepped foot on the lunar surface, a new space race to the Moon is well underway and rapidly gaining momentum. Laying out a vision for the next fifty years, Back to the Moon is astrophysicist Joseph Silk’s persuasive and impassioned case for putting scientific discovery at the forefront of lunar exploration.

Price:$22.95
ISBN:9780691215471 
Published: July 11, 2023
Copyright:2023
Pages:304
Size:5.5 x 8.5 in.
Illus:16 page color insert. 37 b/w illus.
Main_subject: Physics & Astronomy

A concise and accessible introduction to exoplanets that explains the cutting-edge science behind recent discoveries

In The Little Book of Exoplanets, Princeton astrophysicist Joshua Winn offers a brief and engaging introduction to the search for exoplanets and the cutting-edge science behind recent findings. In doing so, he chronicles the dawn of a new age of discovery—one that has rapidly transformed astronomy and our broader understanding of the universe.

Posted in December 2024, Sidereal Times | Tagged | Leave a comment

Snippets

compiled by Arlene & David Kaplan

-NYT

Vast Oceans of Water May Be Hiding Within Uranus and Neptune We might finally understand what’s going on inside Uranus and Neptune, and the answer is pretty surprising: They may each contain an ocean of water. “We didn’t really know anything before,” about their interiors, said Adam Masters, a space and planetary scientist at Imperial College London. “So this hypothesis is very compelling.”…more

-NYT
-NYT

First Close-Up of Star Outside Our Galaxy Shows a Giant About to Blow In a stunning scientific and technological feat, a group of astronomers said Thursday that it had managed to take the first close-up picture of a star in another galaxy. Not only was the image a distance record for such cosmic intimacy, but the star, bulging like an overripe fruit, looks as if it is getting ready to explode…more

-NYT

Can Axions Save the Universe? The search is on for some of the flimsiest lumps of matter and energy ever dreamed up by physicists. They are darker than night, barely more substantial than a thought, and named after a laundry detergent. But axions, as they are called, could constitute most of the matter in our universe, forming the unseen skeletons of galaxies and chains of light that adorn the skies of astronomers….more

-NYT

NASA Says Space Station Astronaut Is in ‘Incredible Health’ Suni Williams, a NASA astronaut currently on the International Space Station, is healthy and not suffering from any medical problems, NASA’s top medical officer said on Thursday. The unusual pronouncement was prompted by news articles suggesting that Ms. Williams was experiencing health problems…more

-NYT

Barnard’s Star Finally Has a Planet, and Possibly More Barnard’s Star is a dim, reddish ball of gas just six light-years away from Earth in the constellation Ophiuchus. It is the nearest stand-alone star to our sun, but with only one-fifth the mass, it is so dim that no one knew it was there until 1916, when the astronomer Edward Emerson Barnard recorded its image on a photographic plate…more

-spacenews

New EU space commissioner outlines priorities The new European Union commissioner responsible for space says he will focus on improving European competitiveness and security in space, including passage of a long-delayed space law. Andrius Kubilius formally started his tenure as the European Commissioner for Defence and Space on Dec. 1 after members of the European Parliament confirmed him among a slate of 26 commissioners Nov. 27 for five-year terms….more

-NYT

An Asteroid’s Destruction May Have Given Mars Rings, Then Moons Something’s not quite right about the moons of Mars. They are too small — Phobos is 17 miles across, and Deimos is a mere nine miles in length. And they aren’t round, but lumpy, misshaped objects. Frankly, they don’t resemble moons at all…more

-NYT

SpaceX Starship’s Sonic Boom Creates Risk of Structural Damage, Test Finds SpaceX’s new Starship rocket far exceeds projected maximum noise levels, generating a sonic boom so powerful it risks property damage in the densely populated residential community near its South Texas launch site, new data suggests…more

-livescience.com

Space photo of the week: James Webb telescope spots a secret star factory in the Sombrero Galaxy It may have been first discovered in 1781, but the aptly named Sombrero Galaxy has never looked like this. This striking new perspective on an icon of the deep sky comes from NASA‘s James Webb Space Telescope, which has rendered the spiral galaxy that looks like a broad-brimmed Mexican hat both in high resolution and at mid-infrared wavelengths for the first time…more

-uchicago.edu

Two Black Holes Are Giving the Cosmos a Fright One is a serial killer, on the verge of devouring its second star in five years. The other is part of what astronomers are calling a black-hole triple, the first known instance of a three-body system that includes a black hole, which is not supposed to be part of the mix, according to standard astrophysics…more

Posted in December 2024, October 2024, Sidereal Times | Tagged , | Leave a comment

From The Director

by Rex Parker, PhD director@princetonastronomers.org

Meeting Nov 12 at Peyton Hall.  We hope to see you in person at Peyton Hall on campus for the next monthly meeting on November 12 (7:30pm).  Our speaker will be Princeton University post-doc Manuel Cuesta from the Dept of Astrophysics, who will discuss his heliophysics research with the Parker Solar Probe.  A lot has been accomplished since launch of the Parker Solar Probe by NASA in August 2018.  The craft was designed and built by Johns Hopkins Applied Physics Laboratory and was named after physicist Eugene Parker, professor emeritus at Univ of Chicago.  For more information about the guest speaker on Nov 12 see program chair Victor Davis’s section below. 

Also at the Nov 12 meeting, member David Ackerman will give a member talk (“unjournal club” after the break) on progress in building and using a spectroheliograph.  This is an optical instrument designed to study the sun at a single wavelength (monochromatic light).  He’ll describe making the instrument using 3-D printing and other methods and will show recent solar data from this instrument of the sun in action at its current peak of activity.

The NASA Situation and What We Can Do.  The Parker Solar Probe is a great recent example of the engineering and science prowess of NASA and collaborators.The Oct 14 launch of NASA’s Europa Clipper on a SpaceX Falcon Heavy rocket was good news and some relief especially after Hurricane Milton crossed Florida and narrowly missed Cape Canaveral the prior week.  Yet despite success in recent science missions and plans to send humans to the moon and Mars in the Artemis and Gateway projects, a sweeping new report from the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine has elevated worries about the future of the space agency.

As I described at the Sept 8 meeting, the “NASA at a Crossroads” report by the National Academy highlighted the results of an in-depth analysis.  It revealed serious deficiencies of NASA’s infrastructure which are critical to future space missions (Figure below, and website https://nap.nationalacademies.org/catalog/27519/nasa-at-a-crossroads-maintaining-workforce-infrastructure-and-technology-preeminence). “Overburdened and underfunded” were terms describing several operations, such as the Deep Space Network, the world-wide array of giant radio antennas supporting interplanetary missions including the Mars rovers operated by JPL.  Without the Deep Space Network, image data from James Webb Space Telescope would not make it to earthside.  The ability to fund NASA’s aging core is especially difficult because of the huge expenses needed for the future lunar and Mars projects.  Most alarmingly, the Academy report described an erosion in engineering expertise, including challenges in being able to recruit top talent in comparison to other organizations and companies.  In other words, the prestige of NASA is not as attractive as it once was in the minds of people entering or advancing in the engineering and scientific fields.

Can we as amateur astronomers do anything to influence the attractiveness to young people of science and engineering education and career tracks in the US?  Nature deficit disorder is a term describing the loss of time spent in the natural environment, especially damaging for kids growing up in cities who may never experience a dark starlit night with milky way glowing overhead. It seems that this has a dampening effect on the psyches of young people as well as adults who might otherwise be much more interested in space sciences and engineering.  As time goes on, the educational pipeline of talented young people finds career outlets in other directions away from the natural sciences and engineering.  So, this is where we as amateur astronomers and space exploration enthusiasts might be able to help.  AAAP’s focus on outreach and bringing astronomy to the public and students can inspire and enable others to find that essential curiosity and love for the celestial sphere and nature as a whole.  We can do our part to help engage people of all ages in embracing astronomy and space sciences.  What else?  This is worthy of more discussion at our upcoming meetings, and I welcome your input.

Looking for Field Trip Proposals.  In years past we’ve had some memorable astronomy field trips for AAAP members.  Most notable was the guided nighttime tour of the US Naval Observatory along with the Smithsonian Air & Space Museum in Washington in Nov 2015.   We also had an excellent local tour of the Princeton Plasma Physics Lab back in Feb 2015.   I would like to hear proposals from you – ideas for astro field trips.  One that comes to my mind is the ”other” Smithsonian Air & Space Museum — the Udvar-Hazy Center near Dulles airport in the DC area.

After the Break.  One of the ways we promote astronomy is to highlight member activities in the second half of our monthly meetings, after the break. We also reserve a slot after the break for the Unjournal Club, in which members have the floor (and screen) to discuss recent astro-related articles from the journals and magazines or other personal astronomy experiences and projects to share with fellow members.  Just shoot an email to me, or to the Program Chair, to hold a place at upcoming meetings.  If you have images, slides, or other content to share, please note that it’s best to bring them on a USB drive to insert into my already-connected laptop to show during the meeting.

Check Out the AAAP YouTube Channel.  Our monthly meetings at Peyton Hall are simulcast live via Zoom, and the recordings are converted to YouTube and (after editing) posted on the AAAP YouTube Channel.  The videos are a great way to view the meetings you may have missed or review parts that may have been hard to grasp, since some of our topics do go pretty deep.  The AAAP YouTube channel currently offers over 60 videos produced inside AAAP during the last few years (thanks to Victor, Dave, and Ira!) and has gathered well over 9000 views to date.  Beyond recordings of the meetings and guest speaker presentations, it features how-to videos, cool celestial events from the observatory, astro video sessions from member telescopes, and interviews with knowledgeable club members. Here’s the link: https://www.youtube.com/@amateurastronomersassociat1439

Posted in November 2024, Sidereal Times | Tagged , | Leave a comment

From The Program Chair

by Victor Davis, Program Chair

November Meeting

The November, 2024 meeting of the AAAP will take place in Peyton Hall on the campus of Princeton University on Tuesday, November 12th at 7:30 PM. As usual, the meeting is open to AAAP members and the public. Participants can join the meeting in-person at Peyton Hall or log in to the Zoom session as early as 7:00 pm to chat informally before the meeting begins. The evening’s guest speaker is Princeton Postdoc Manuel Cuesta, who will give a talk on remote observations of solar dynamics, including recent research using the Parker Solar Probe.

Options for Attending the Meeting

You may choose to attend the meeting in person or participate via Zoom or YouTube as we’ve been doing for the past few years. (See How to Participate below for details). Due to security concerns, if you log in before the host has set up internet connectivity in Peyton Hall, you may need to wait in the Waiting Room for a few minutes until the host is prepared to admit you into the meeting. You’ll need to unmute yourself to make comments or ask questions. It’s polite, though not required, for you to enable your camera so other participants can see you. A week or so after the meeting, the video of the lecture and Q&A will be posted on AAAP’s public YouTube channel.

The traditional “meet the speaker” dinner will be held at Winberie’s Restaurant & Bar, One Palmer Square, Princeton, NJ. Reservation is for 5:45 pm. Please advise the Program Chair if you plan to attend.

Here’s the anticipated agenda for November, 2024’s monthly meeting of the AAAP:

(Times are approximate)

Getting to Peyton Hall
The parking lots across the street (Ivy Lane) from Peyton Hall are now construction sites, unavailable for parking. We’ve been advised by the administration of the astrophysics department that we should park in the new enclosed parking garage off Fitzrandolph street and walk around the stadium and athletic fields. Here’s a map of the campus and walking routes from the parking garage to Peyton Hall. The map shows the recently completed East Garage. Not shown is an access road Sweet Gum that connects from Faculty Road to an entrance at the lower left corner of the garage. Stadium Road connects from Fitzrandolph Road to another entrance at the opposite corner (and higher level) of the garage. It’s about a 10-15 minute walk from the parking garage to Peyton Hall.

Remote Observations of Solar Dynamics and Results from the Parker Solar Probe
One of the key discoveries leading up to the space age was the solar wind, which permeates interplanetary space throughout the heliosphere. Dr. Cuesta will review the history of remote observations of such solar dynamics.  He will discuss the impact of space physics research involving the investigation of space weather with the goal of predicting extreme solar events, which cause large disruptions of the solar wind. Coronal mass ejections, for example, usually carry with them enhanced particle populations accelerated to very high energy. These high energy particles and mass ejections of plasma sometimes ram into the Earth, causing power-grids to shut down, increasing radiation exposure to people in mid-flight, and communication disruptions. The Parker Solar Probe mission is the project that aims to answer many of the unsolved questions in field of space physics, such as sources of particle acceleration and their mechanisms, the main driver(s) of the solar wind, and the coronal heating problem. Dr. Cuesta’s  presentation gives some of the first results from this mission and some current topics of ongoing research in the Space Physics Group here at Princeton University.

Manuel Cuesta
Dr. Cuesta earned his Ph.D. in Physics at the University of Delaware. For his thesis, he worked on the radial evolution of turbulence intermittency in the solar wind in comparison to well-known quantities in hydrodynamic turbulence, as well as anisotropy and compressibility, finding that the solar wind in many ways behaves like a wind tunnel.  He has analyzed data measured in situ via numerous spacecraft missions including NASA’s Parker Solar Probe, Helios 1, Advanced Composition Explorer, Wind, Magnetospheric Multi-Scale, and Voyager 1. He was awarded the Donald L. Turcotte Award from the American Geophysical Union in recognition of his outstanding dissertation research for potential contributions to the field of nonlinear geophysics. He currently conducts research at the Department of Astrophysical Sciences at Princeton University relevant to energetic particles and their interaction with solar wind dynamics. 

How to Participate (Links)

Meeting link Meeting link
Click the above icons for Zoom and YouTube

Date Featured SpeakerTopic
December 10, 2024
Jesse Christiansen
christia.ipac.caltech.edu

Dr. Christiansen is Senior Scientist at NASA’s Exoplanet Science Institute at Caltech. She’ll describe her research and the current status of Exoplanet discoveries. 
January 12,
2025
Rebecca Boyle
rebecca.b.boyle@gmail.com

Rebecca Boyle, science writer, essayist, and Contributing Editor to Scientific American, will discuss her new book, “Our Moon: How Earth’s Celestial Companion Transformed the Planet, Guided Evolution, and Made Us Who We Are.”  Suggested by Ira Polans.

As always, members’ comments and suggestions are gratefully accepted and much appreciated.

victor.davis@verizon.net
program@princetonastronomers
(908) 581-1780 cell

Posted in November 2024, Sidereal Times | Tagged , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Minutes of the October 8, 2024 Meeting

by Gene Allen, Secretary

Director Rex Parker opened the meeting in Peyton Hall and on Zoom at 1934. There were 35 in attendance and 43 were noted online.

Rex reported that the 2024 Nobel Prize in Physics has been awarded to Princeton University Professor Emeritus Dr John Hopfield. Rex did some research and found that there are an impressive 79 Nobel laureates among PU faculty.

He continued to say that fall observing targets are coming into view and comet C/2023 A3 is expected to present great views as it emerges from behind the Sun. Saturn is just past opposition, so at its brightest for the year, with its rings nearly edge on. The launch of Europa Clipper to study that moon of Jupiter up close and personal is imminent.

Program Chair Victor Davis introduced St. Joseph’s University Professor Paul Halpen and his lecture, “The Allure of the Multiverse; Beyond the Limits of Direct Observation.” It is based on his similarly titled book, “The Allure of the Multiverse: Extra Dimensions, Other Worlds, and Parallel Universes.”

Questions and a break followed his talk. Books were available for purchase and Dr Halpen was signing them.

Rex reconvened the meeting at 2116 with 11 in attendance. He described astrophotos which include landscape elements as enabled and championed by PhotoPills software. Planetary astrophotography discussion ensued, dealing with image scale and the rate of retention of frames during stacking. In general, the best results are obtained with the highest gain and shortest exposure plus an image scale appropriate to your observing conditions. Retention rates chosen during stacking varied from 20% (Rex) to 50% (Member Tom Swords) to 100% (Assistant Director Bob Vanderbei). The best planetary results, regardless of technique, generally require a bazillion exposures.

A number of members are planning to try to capture the comet at the low western horizon available at the soccer fields near the observatory in the middle of next week.

Outreach Chair Bill Murray reported upcoming outreach events on 10/10, 10/18, and 10/22 which will have passed before these minutes publish. Hopefully additional members will turn out to support these events. A fourth event is on November 2, from 1730-2230 at the Mercer Meadows Pole Farm. If you can bring a scope please let Bill know.

Merchandise Shop Lead Facilitator Rich Sherman reported the changeover to winter clothing articles has been accomplished. Due to frequently long lead times on fulfilling orders, he recommends ordering very early for Christmas. He reported that the AAAP has profited $350 from merchandise sales and recommends the book “Before the Big Bang.”

The meeting was adjourned at 2155.

Posted in November 2024, Sidereal Times | Tagged , | Leave a comment

Documentary Screening at IAS

by Lee Sandberg

I have an event that will likely be of interest to the membership. On Nov. 15 at 5:00pm, the Institute for Advanced Study will host a public screening of the documentary film “The Hunt for Planet B“. This will be followed by a panel discussion with filmmaker Nathaniel Kahn, Art History Professor Maria Loh, renowned astronomer Sara Seager, and former Chief Scientist – NASA Headquarters Jim Green. Registration details are available here: https://www.ias.edu/events/st-lee-film-screening-november-15-2024 I am happy to answer any questions before I leave for my travels on Nov. 12. You can reach me at
lsandberg205@gmail.com

Posted in November 2024, Sidereal Times | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

Time

by John Church

Time, in and of itself, flows equably without relation to any external thing.
– Isaac Newton

My granddaughter Nora once asked her mother where time comes from. Hmm! No one has ever been able to really answer this question. Poets and essayists have debated it for as long as we have had written languages.

Some maintain that there is no such thing as time; it’s all in our minds, a strictly psychological effect. For example, how can we decide whether we pass through time, or whether time passes through us? What is the duration of a moment? Metaphysics 101: does time pass more quickly when we’re having fun? These and similar questions are variants of the old “egocentric predicament,” or the problem of deciding if a reality external to our own perception actually does exist. Questions like this continue to provide employment for philosophers.

I’m prepared to allow that psychological or subjective time does have an inner if somewhat tenuous reality. On the other hand, as a physical chemist specializing in kinetics, I’ve studied the objective effects of time many “times” in the laboratory. Time does have a real and independent existence there. With physical objects, Newtonian mechanics works very well, even with space probes; but things can be much different under extreme conditions, such as in or near black holes.

We all know about the one-way passage of time from daily experience. My morning coffee can’t be unbrewed, my toast untoasted, or my scrambled eggs unscrambled. These are everyday examples of irreversible events, accompanied by an increase in disorder (entropy) and a decrease in “free energy,” to use the chemical term. Unusual word choice – we all know that energy isn’t free in the economic sense.

But it doesn’t work that way with living things, at least not for a while. Children grow, learn how to speak and read and write and ask hard questions, and maybe even invent calculus. Life temporarily defeats the destructive effects of time, in apparent if not real contradiction of the laws of thermodynamics. I say apparent, because living things create order within themselves only at the expense of creating more disorder in the environment. Yet there is a pervasive, organizing life force – on Earth anyway – that temporarily cancels the general tendency of things to become more disorganized and go to lower “free energy” states as time passes.

Regarding this, I have a personal anecdote. A bumblebee was caught in my bedroom window in the space between the inner sash and the storm sash, both of which were closed. I must have accidentally trapped it. I wanted to release the poor creature, but how could I do this safely? If I lifted up the inner sash in order to get at the storm sash and open it, the bee might sting me or fly into the house before I could get the storm sash open. So I did nothing for a couple of days. The bee gradually got weaker, and finally just sat lethargically on the inner window sill, shrunken and nearly dead. An idea came to me. I made up a little sugar water and got a medicine dropper. I lifted up the inner sash, ready to close it again if the bee stirred. (It didn’t.) I opened the storm sash several inches, placed a little pool of the sugar water right under the bee’s face, quickly closed the inner sash, and watched. The surprised bee tasted the sugar water. Then it began to lap it up, very slowly at first. After a few seconds it rested. Then it began to breathe deeply through its abdomen, which swelled and contracted. It eagerly lapped up more sugar water, faster now. Spurred on by rapid enzymatic reactions, the bee quickly came back to life. It lifted its wings off its back and began to tremble with anticipation. It gathered strength. It buzzed. It lifted off. It flew around inside the window for a few seconds, then found the opening and sped off into my front yard as if nothing had ever happened. Life had won again.

We know that time cannot be shielded against, stopped, or made to go backwards. Neither can gravitation. Time and gravitation must be deeply connected, not just near the Earth of course but throughout all of space. Is this a coincidence? Does one possibly cause the other, or are they completely independent?

Edgar Allan Poe’s theory, expounded in his 1848 essay Eureka, is that gravitation is simply the reaction of matter to having been thrown out (“radiated” he called it, drawing a parallel with light) from a primordial particle at the beginning of time. Cosmologists and physicists have never yet succeeded in explaining why gravitation exists; they usually just say “it is” and stop there, rarely if ever referencing Poe’s anticipation of the Big Bang and what, to him, seemed its logical consequence. Poe’s additional theory as to why the night sky is dark (the “Olbers paradox”) may have been the first correct explanation: light from the farthest reaches simply hasn’t had enough time to reach us yet.

People have been looking for antigravity devices about as long as they have been trying to stop time or make it go backwards. We can freeze light rays in a photograph, but we can’t freeze gravitation. It is a slow unforgiving force which might eventually collapse the entire universe. The first person who invents a way to stop or reverse time will probably also have invented a way to stop or reverse its alter ego, gravitation. And vice versa. Let the games begin. Down to the workshop! I’ve got a prototype of an
antigravity machine (not a helicopter). Would you like to buy some of my stock?

Posted in November 2024, Sidereal Times | Tagged | Leave a comment

Hubble Tension

by S. Prasad Ganti

Edwin Hubble was the legendary astronomer of the early twentieth century. Credited with the discoveries of the Andromeda galaxy and the expansion of the universe. With these, he brought the concept of galaxies to our lexicon. And that the size of our universe is ever expanding. This eventually led to the postulation of the Big Bang theory and the birth of the universe from such a humble beginning. 

Hubble used the 100 inch Hooker telescope on Mount Wilson in California to come up with his historic observations. He measured distances to different stars using standard candles – stars whose absolute brightness can be determined and whose apparent brightness as seen from Earth can be measured. First standard candle is a star known as the Cepheid variable which was discovered by Henrietta Leavitt. These stars vary cyclically in brightness over an interval of time. This interval is proportional to its absolute brightness. Leavitt observed the brightness of different Cepheid variables and their periods. By determining the distance of few such stars using other methods like parallax (which work for stars at smaller distances), she was able to plot the brightness cycle vs. distances.   

Hubble observed more Cepheid variables in what appeared to be distant nebulae. He found that the distances  of such nebulae are much more than what was the known size of our galaxy, the Milky Way. That is how he discovered the Andromeda galaxy, our nearest neighbor. He then discovered several galaxies distinct from the Milky Way. He found their distances by making an assumption that the brightest star in every galaxy is equally bright.

Along with different galaxies, he also found something surprising. That the galaxies are moving away from each other. He found this using the redshift of the light coming from that galaxy. The color of light changes if the source is moving towards us or away from us. The color change is apparent only at high speeds, not like a few miles per hour. Light from sources moving away from us will be shifted towards the red end of the spectrum. While light from any source moving towards us will be shifted towards the blue end of the spectrum. Hubble concluded that the further a galaxy is away from us, the faster it is moving away from us. 

The expansion of the universe was formulated into an equation which had “Hubble’s constant” as one of the parameters. He attempted to measure the value of this constant given the distance of the galaxies and the red shift they were producing. He went through several iterations before settling on a value. More recent observations resulted in more precise calculations and a better value. 

A second way of calculating the Hubble’s constant is by looking at the CMB (Cosmic Microwave Background) pattern of the universe produced by several space based observatories – COBE (Cosmic Background Explorer), WMAP (Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe), and Planck. The results from the two methods differ by a non-trivial amount. This discrepancy is known as “Hubble tension”. 

The discrepancy was resolved in 1998 by postulating that the expansion of the universe is accelerating. And that dark energy is responsible for such an accelerated expansion. Now dark energy is accepted as a part of the “standard model” of our universe. Yet some discrepancy still exists between the values calculated using two different methods.

If the two methods  yield values close enough, then the standard model is validated again. Work continues in this area. More progress is expected when two observatories start getting the first light. Vera Rubin observatory is being built in Chile. It is expected to see the first light in 2025. A space based telescope Nancy Grace Roman is expected to be launched towards the end of 2026. 

With newer discoveries, hope is that the “Hubble tension” will be eased if not erased. 

Posted in November 2024, Sidereal Times | Tagged , | Leave a comment

The Curse is Broken!

by Gene Allen

For many reasons I’m sure, I have been unable to observe any comet, either visually or with photography, with the naked eye, binoculars, iPhone cameras, DSLRs, telescopes with eyepieces, or telescopes with cameras. This condition has prevailed for decades. Recently everybody reports seeing C-2023 A3, and some show me pictures they took on their phones quite effortlessly, even neighbors who are virtually never astronomers. It truly makes me feel as if I were the victim of some nefarious “no comets for you!” curse.

Tonight I took my little ZWO Seestar S50 to a school in nearby Robbinsville to support a AAAP outreach event for a Girl Scout troop. Not too cold yet, and fairly decent skies, I was hopeful to share some of the DSOs (Deep Sky Objects) it captures so handily. I have not yet worked out why it has trouble with the first target and needs manual pointing, but from then it’s spot on. After struggling a bit trying for Venus as it slipped into the trees, Saturn was centered on the screen, and I figured what the heck, why not take one more stab at that #*$& comet?

And there it was, blooming from a tiny speck as the 10 second images stacked in what ZWO calls “enhancing.” It was a popular spectacle, on both my iPhone and iPad, when intently searching the night sky clearly showed a big, fat nuthin’.

The view was reframed, moving the core down from center to better show the tail, and the stack restarted. While the tail did intensify as the images accumulated, I noticed that the core “extended” into a bar. My first thought was field rotation, that bane of alt-az mounts with longer exposures. What little I understand about it seems to involve a degrading of the edges of the field, not this growing bar, with the stars in the background staying pretty circular, at least by EAA (Electronically Assisted Astronomy) standards. Those far more capable at this stuff can chime in, but I conclude that the bar shows the movement of the comet away from us over the duration of the total exposure. Instead of a fault with the image, it’s actually some neat and, to me, unexpected evidence.

The smaller pictures on the side are enlargements of the core at 3, 6, and 13 minutes of exposure. Even the 3 minute one is less than round.

The leaders and parents were more excited than the scouts about what the five of us were able to show them, but I’m convinced that the best rewards of the night came to me.

As you can see, anyone can do it. Grab whatever binoculars or telescope you have, and bring your enthusiasm to an outreach event.

Posted in Sidereal Times | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment